This private barrel select from Penelope Bourbon showcases why the brand’s toasted series has become a fan favorite among bourbon enthusiasts. Bottled at 116 proof, this expression balances bold barrel character with Penelope’s signature smooth, layered profile.
Nose:
The aroma opens with inviting waves of caramelized sugar, toasted marshmallow, and vanilla bean, underscored by warm oak and a hint of smoked honey from the heavy toast. There’s a subtle nutty sweetness—like roasted pecans or hazelnuts—alongside light baking spice.
Palate:
Rich and full-bodied, the sip delivers a burst of maple syrup, charred oak, and butterscotch, followed by graham cracker and cinnamon. The char level 1 barrel keeps the oak influence restrained, allowing the toasted sugars and grain sweetness to shine through. The mouthfeel is creamy yet robust, with a touch of dark chocolate and toffee developing mid-palate.
Finish:
Long and warming, with lingering vanilla cream, charred oak, and brown sugar glaze. The 116 proof adds heat but never overwhelms—the balance between spice, sweetness, and oak is remarkably well-tuned.
Overall Impression:
This private barrel of Penelope Toasted Bourbon is a standout example of how a low char, heavy toast profile can bring deep flavor without overbearing bitterness. It’s a dessert-forward bourbon with enough spice and proof to keep seasoned drinkers engaged. Fans of toasted barrel finishes will find this one both elegant and satisfying—a perfect sipper neat or with a single cube.
Rating: ★★★★☆ (4.5/5) – Richly toasted, perfectly proofed, and beautifully balanced.
This private barrel select from Penelope Bourbon showcases why the brand’s toasted series has become a fan favorite among bourbon enthusiasts. Bottled at 116 proof, this expression balances bold barrel character with Penelope’s signature smooth, layered profile.
Nose:
The aroma opens with inviting waves of caramelized sugar, toasted marshmallow, and vanilla bean, underscored by warm oak and a hint of smoked honey from the heavy toast. There’s a subtle nutty sweetness—like roasted pecans or hazelnuts—alongside light baking spice.
Palate:
Rich and full-bodied, the sip delivers a burst of maple syrup, charred oak, and butterscotch, followed by graham cracker and cinnamon. The char level 1 barrel keeps the oak influence restrained, allowing the toasted sugars and grain sweetness to shine through. The mouthfeel is creamy yet robust, with a touch of dark chocolate and toffee developing mid-palate.
Finish:
Long and warming, with lingering vanilla cream, charred oak, and brown sugar glaze. The 116 proof adds heat but never overwhelms—the balance between spice, sweetness, and oak is remarkably well-tuned.
Overall Impression:
This private barrel of Penelope Toasted Bourbon is a standout example of how a low char, heavy toast profile can bring deep flavor without overbearing bitterness. It’s a dessert-forward bourbon with enough spice and proof to keep seasoned drinkers engaged. Fans of toasted barrel finishes will find this one both elegant and satisfying—a perfect sipper neat or with a single cube.
Rating: ★★★★☆ (4.5/5) – Richly toasted, perfectly proofed, and beautifully balanced.
